Nipple Shields for Comfort: A Complete Guide for New Moms

Breastfeeding can be a beautiful experience, but it doesn’t always come easy. Many new moms face latch issues, nipple pain, or premature births that affect the feeding process. Thankfully, nipple shields — especially those designed for comfort — offer an effective solution. Whether you’re dealing with flat nipples or a fussy latch, the right nipple shield can ease your journey.

In this guide, we’ll explore the best nipple shields for comfort, including their pros, cons, pricing, and where to buy them. You’ll also find expert advice and helpful insights from real moms.

---

What Are Nipple Shields?

Nipple shields are thin silicone covers worn over the nipple during breastfeeding. They help babies latch easier and reduce nipple pain. These shields are typically clear, flexible, and have small holes at the tip for milk flow.

Many new moms and lactation consultants recommend nipple shields for comfort during the first few challenging weeks of breastfeeding. Some shields even support skin-to-skin contact, which helps baby and mom bond better.

---

Why Moms Use Nipple Shields

Nipple shields serve multiple purposes. They can be helpful for:

• Moms with flat or inverted nipples.
• Sore or cracked nipples from poor latching.
• Preemies or babies with weak suction.
• Babies with tongue ties or shallow latches.

Dr. Suzanne Chan, a board-certified pediatric nurse practitioner and certified lactation counselor, says nipple shields support breastfeeding success. They promote secure latching and reduce discomfort.

---

Choosing the Best Nipple Shields for Comfort

When selecting a shield, consider these features:

Size Options

Some nipple shields come in various sizes (measured in millimeters). A proper fit improves latch and comfort.

Material

Silicone is soft, durable, and easy to clean. It’s also clear, so you can check the baby’s latch.

Shape

Shield shapes vary based on nipple type. Ask a lactation consultant for personalized recommendations.

Cleaning Ease

Clean shields properly to prevent bacteria buildup. Boiling or hot soapy water usually works well.

Now, let’s explore our top picks.

---

Best Overall: Medela Nipple Shield

• Material: Silicone
• Sizes: 16 mm, 20 mm, 24 mm
• Case Included: Yes
• Cleaning: Boil for 20 minutes or wash in hot soapy water

Pros:

• Available in multiple sizes
• Cutout allows skin-to-skin contact
• Comes with a case

Cons:

• Some retailers may not offer all sizes

Moms love Medela’s Contact Nipple Shield for easing the breastfeeding process. The ultra-thin silicone allows skin contact and promotes a natural feel. These nipple shields for comfort help babies learn to latch while easing nipple pain.

Many moms with flat nipples say this product extended their breastfeeding journey. The shields are small, thin, and comfortable. You might even forget you’re wearing one!

---

Best for Tongue Tie: Lansinoh Contact Nipple Shield

• Material: Silicone
• Sizes: 20 mm, 24 mm
• Case Included: Yes
• Cleaning: Hand wash or boil for 5 minutes

Pros:

• Affordable
• Includes carrying case
• Cutout improves latch for tongue-tied babies

Cons:

• Limited size options

Babies with tongue ties often struggle with shallow latching. Lansinoh’s shield features a low-profile design that aids latch formation. It’s also a great short-term solution until a tongue tie is resolved.

Even if your baby doesn’t have a tongue tie, this shield is effective and affordable. Moms say it resembles the Medela shield in comfort and design.

---

Best for Large Nipples: Dr. Brown’s Nipple Shields

• Material: Silicone
• Sizes: 25 mm and up
• Case Included: Yes
• Cleaning: Hand wash or boil in water

Pros:

• One of the few shields for large nipples
• Includes storage case
• Extra holes prevent milk pooling

Cons:

• Pricier than most
• Some babies struggle with the shape

Dr. Brown’s shields are perfect for moms needing larger sizes. Most shields cap at 24 mm, but this brand goes beyond. It’s also great if you experience milk oversupply.

The soft silicone feels natural, but some moms say it’s too flimsy. The unique shape doesn’t work for all babies, so try it with supervision.

---

Best Budget Option: Purifyou Nipple Shield

• Material: Silicone
• Sizes: 16 mm, 18 mm, 20 mm, 24 mm
• Case Included: Yes
• Cleaning: Hand wash or boil for at least 2 minutes

Pros:

• Very affordable
• Wide size range, including 18 mm
• Stays in place well

Cons:

• Some babies prefer other brands

Purifyou’s design mimics the natural breast shape, helping the shield stay in place during feeding. Moms also love the included case, which can double as a pacifier holder.

Many say these shields “saved” their breastfeeding journey. These nipple shields for comfort make feeding easier and more manageable for both baby and mom.

---

Best for Bottle to Breast Transition: Haakaa Nipple Shield

• Material: Silicone
• Sizes: 22 mm (round or triangle base)
• Case Included: No
• Cleaning: Hand wash or boil for 2–3 minutes

Pros:

• Anti-slip features
• Great for bottle-fed babies
• Available in two base shapes

Cons:

• Expensive for just one
• Slight surface texture may bother some babies

Haakaa’s shield is ideal if you’re switching from bottle to breastfeeding. It features anti-slip grips and two base styles for flexibility. Though pricey, it’s worth trying if your baby prefers bottle nipples.

The triangle base may feel more natural for babies used to bottles. Moms also report fewer feeding disruptions thanks to the shield’s grip and softness.

---

Best Nipple Shield for Short Nipples: Haakaa Silicone Nipple Shield

• Sizes Available: 15 mm
• Material: Silicone
• Quantity: 2
• Case Included: No

Pros:

• Ideal for shorter or smaller nipples.
• Dishwasher-safe for easy cleaning.

Cons:

• May be too small for those with larger nipples

The Haakaa Silicone Nipple Shield is ideal for shorter or smaller nipples. Its 15 mm size is among the smallest available, with a natural shape that supports easier latching. The ultra-thin silicone and curved top let baby stay close to your skin. Plus, it’s one of the few dishwasher-safe options for hassle-free cleaning.

---

Best Nipple Shield for Flat or Inverted Nipples: Haakaa Two-Pack Inverted Nipple Correctors

• Sizes Available: One size (1.81 x 1.14 x 3.39 inches)
• Material: Silicone
• Quantity: 2
• Case Included: Yes

Pros:

• Specifically designed for flat or inverted nipples.
• Dishwasher safe for convenience.

Cons:

• Pricier compared to other nipple shields.

Flat or inverted nipples can make breastfeeding tricky, but it’s definitely doable with the right support. Haakaa Inverted Nipple Correctors use gentle suction to draw out nipples before feeding, making latching easier. Unlike traditional nipple shields, these are used before nursing and removed before baby latches. Each use lasts around two hours and needs to be repeated before every feed. They come in a set of two, include a storage case, and are dishwasher-safe for easy cleaning.

---

When to Consult a Lactation Expert

While nipple shields help many moms, they aren’t a one-size-fits-all solution. If you experience pain, poor latch, or low milk transfer, consult a lactation expert.

A certified lactation consultant can help you:

• Choose the right size and shape
• Ensure proper latch and milk flow
• Create a plan to wean off shields if needed

Remember, using nipple shields for comfort doesn’t mean you’re doing anything wrong. You’re simply finding the right tools to support your journey.

---

Tips for Using Nipple Shields Safely

• Sterilize before each use to avoid germs.
• Ensure correct placement to maintain latch and milk flow.
• Monitor baby’s weight and milk intake with your pediatrician.
• Store shields in a clean case between uses.
• Use shields short-term unless advised otherwise by a professional.

---

Final Thoughts: Support Makes a Difference

Breastfeeding is a learning process, and the right tools can make all the difference. Nipple shields for comfort offer moms relief and babies better access to milk. With proper use, they can transform a frustrating experience into a positive one.

Whether you’re easing into nursing or facing latch struggles, one of the shields above may help you succeed. Choose what fits your needs and don’t hesitate to seek help.

---

Explore More

Want more support, reviews, and parenting tips?
Explore more news on this website and continue your breastfeeding journey with confidence.